47 replies to this topic

[Cliffy]

I'm Gonna Go with Orion

[ThePhantomLord666]

i chose Orion but if i had to choose a second it would be between Ktulu and SR

[Phil's Username]

I chose Orion, but Ktulu with the orchestra was pretty fantastic as well.

[LongHairedAussieGuy]

Pulling Teeth and Orion both are a tie imo

[Evil Eye]

Ktulu and TLITD are leagues above the other two.

[lordcatfish]

Ktulu>>>>>>S&R>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Orion>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>TLitD

[Zalman]

I'm going to support S&R. Not sure where I'd place the others, but Ktulu is definitely my least favorite, even though it still kicks ass.

Oh wait, forget it, Anetheasia is my least favorite. I always forget about it and I don't think of it whenever I hear "Metallica's instrumentals". It's more like a filler. I find it boring and a waste of time.

Edited by Zalman, Dec 02 10 - 07:11 AM.

[Evil Eye]

Oh wait, forget it, Anetheasia is my least favorite. I always forget about it and I don't think of it whenever I hear "Metallica's instrumentals". It's more like a filler. I find it boring and a waste of time.

This. It'd have been better if they'd just shortened it and used it as an intro for Whiplash.
Also, Kamen's version of Ecstasy > the original. No stupid sounding female opera vocals.

[ThePhantomLord666]

I'm going to support S&R. Not sure where I'd place the others, but Ktulu is definitely my least favorite, even though it still kicks ass.

Oh wait, forget it, Anetheasia is my least favorite. I always forget about it and I don't think of it whenever I hear "Metallica's instrumentals". It's more like a filler. I find it boring and a waste of time.

THATS CLIVE BURTON YOUR TALKING ABOUT!!!! *puts on angry ranting mask*

[Fedryktulu]

IMO, orion, to live is to die and ktulu are just as good. I voted orion because I literally never get tired of it.

[Hetfield 09]

Tough one between "Orion" and "To Live Is To Die".

[And Thunder For All]

Orion

[PhantomLord81]

Ktulu
Suicide
Orion
TLITD
Anesthesia
Ecstasy

[farshad.roger]

Orion
S&R
Ktulu
TLITD

[mrd1982]

Orion

No contest!

[RideZeLightning]

Time and time again, it's Orion. Simply fantastic and a head above all others.

[Fedryktulu]

Still have no idea what people hear in Orion that makes it so great. I think Ktulu and TLITD are leagues above it...

Everybody gets something different from every song.

[jawakiller227]

to live is to die you have to lve that song

[Flight 666]

To Live is to Die, mainly because of the middle section. That part has me feelin some type of way. Beautiful.

My dumbass friend doesn't consider it to be an instrumental simply because of the SPOKEN words.

[Flight 666]

Still have no idea what people hear in Orion that makes it so great. I think Ktulu and TLITD are leagues above it...

Orion bores me quite well.

[DamnatioMemoriae]

Orion

100 empty spots

The rest

empty spot

SR

[JusticeIsRaped]

TLITD
Ktulu
Orion
S&R
Teeth

[Sebcore1]

1-TLITD
2-Orion
3-Ktullu
4-anastesia











5-S and R

[...JusticeForAll]

To Live is to Die
S&R
Ktulu
Orion
Pulling Teeth

[xSSJ4x]

Ktulu is by far my fav. And I also think it's the best. Pulling teeth is a more of a jam then a song and cant really compete with the other giants. Orion is a awesome instrumental but i think where ktulu wins out is that u listen to it and u really can image the monster/mythical creature it is about coming to life. The montrous bass squeals and bellows it's just awesome. plus I just love the intro so much. It starts slow and light and then rises into a beast that feels to just build and build until the solo just explodes. And the outro really does have it all. And if you Listen to the recorded, s&m and a couple of live versions you get to hear layers of the song that shine out differently in each version giving u different perspectives of each part. Live/die defiantly has alot of feeling and u can just tell the guys are really putting their hearts into the way they play. but as a song I think Orion and ktulu are superior.

But really they are just so close and i really think that it's just personal preference. I just love ktulu so much and I never get sick of listening to it. As you prob could have guessed that =P